The Defense of Computers, the Internet and Our Brains - Bits Blog - NYTimes.comThe Defense of Computers, the Internet and Our Brains - Bits Blog - NYTimes.comPlease consider making a donation to the Widow's and Children's Fund managed by the Uniformed Firefighters Association of Greater New York.
Thank you!
Today's Paper
Most Popular
Times Topics
Search All NYTimes.com
Business Day
Technology
N.Y. / Region
Real Estate
Search Technology
Business Computing
Bits Blog »
Personal Tech »
Digital Cameras
Cellphones
All Products
Digital Camcorders
E-Book Readers
Headsets & Accessories
Music Players
Video Players
Portable Computers
June 11, 2010, 1:24 pm
— Updated: 1:55 pm
By NICK BILTON
Charles Baldwin for The New York Times
Several studies show that video games and the Web stimulate areas of the brain associated with memory, hand and eye coordination and attention.
If you’re reading this blog post on a computer, mobile phone or e-reader, please stop what you’re doing immediately. You could be making yourself stupid. And whatever you do, don’t click on the links in this post. They could distract you from the flow of my beautiful prose and narrative.
This is is the alarm currently being rung by some in the bell towers of technology.
There is a lively discussion and some concern that computers, the Internet and multitasking are extracting a mental price .
Nicholas Carr
The Shallows
plenty of others in this camp
Steven Pinker
Op-Ed page
Professor Pinker points out that our brains are intended to be rewired and learn new things. It’s the way we are built:
Critics of new media sometimes use science itself to press their case, citing research that shows how “experience can change the brain.� But cognitive neuroscientists roll their eyes at such talk. Yes, every time we learn a fact or skill the wiring of the brain changes; it’s not as if the information is stored in the pancreas. But the existence of neural plasticity does not mean the brain is a blob of clay pounded into shape by experience.
Jonah Lehrer, author of “ How We Decide ,” also argues that our brains are likely just fine on the Internet. Mr. Lehrer, a former neuroscientist, writes on his blog, The Frontal Cortex , that “given this paucity of evidence, I think it’s far too soon to be drawing firm conclusions about the negative effects of the Web.”
In a recent blog post Mr. Lehrer notes that the evidence critics use to attack the Web could be used to argue that we shouldn’t even walk down a city street as the cognitive load is far too great for our brains to handle. He notes that a in 2008, a group of scientists from the University of Michigan engaged in a study that showed walking led the brain to see a “dramatic decreases in working memory, self-control, visual attention and positive affect.” Mr Lehrer writes:
When people walk down the street, they are forced to exert cognitive control and top-down attention, and all that mental effort takes a temporary toll on their brain.
Based on this data, it would be easy to conclude that we should avoid the metropolis, that the city street is a hazardous place.
Then there is the reality that our brains, the tool that you, the reader, are currently using to decode these symbols and understand what they mean, has still not evolved to naturally learn to read: reading is an unnatural task that we still need to train our brains to learn.
Maryanne Wol
Room for Debate
After many years of research on how the human brain learns to read, I came to an unsettlingly simple conclusion: We humans were never born to read. We learn to do so by an extraordinarily ingenuous ability to rearrange our “original parts� — like language and vision, both of which have genetic programs that unfold in fairly orderly fashion within any nurturant environment. Reading isn’t like that.
Ms. Wolf, who is concerned about the effects of the Web on children, recently explained in a phone interview that although our brains are not designed to read, the act and process children go through when decoding letters and narrative is an imperative part of a child’s development and thinking.
Ms. Wolf points out different media have value. “I’m not saying other mediums and technologies are not good for the brain, research shows that they are,” she said, “but we must understand the use of visual auditory narratives so we don’t neglect the role of the reading circuit.”
Research shows that each medium offers its own positive attributes: Neuroscience has shown that playing video games stimulates areas of our brains that control working memory, hand and eye coordination and attention and can stimulate and vastly improve our cognitive skills. Reading on the other hand promotes deep thought and exercises areas of the brain responsible for reflection, reasoning and critical analysis. And auditory storytelling stimulates areas of the brain involved with creativity, contextual thinking and executive function.
It could be argued that the Web, which is the ultimate library of words, video, images, interactivity, sharing and conversation, is the quintessential place to learn.
E-mail This
Consumer Electronics
Phones and Mobile Devices
Policy and Law
Technology and Society
social networking
brain research
psychology
world wide web
What We’re Reading: iPad’s Price, EBay Thieves and Palm’s Decline
Bits Scan: Pirate Bay, the Internet River and a Google Patent
Bits Scan: Inside Google, the Future of Gaming and Data Breaches
Foursquare Teams With Bravo TV
The Internet Traffic Challenge: The Policy Dimension
Previous post
Aviary Introduces Free Online Music Software
Google News Gives News Orgs a Chance to Stand Out
Gadgetwise
Media Decoder
Green Inc.
Bringing Comparison Shopping to the Doctor’s Office
Dell in Talks to Resolve Intel Inquiry With S.E.C.
F.B.I. Investigates Leak of iPad E-Mail Addresses
More on Technology »
Two Wheels, High Drama and an App
Place Your Bets
Today Is the Day to Sell a Used iPhone
Visit the Blog »
Speed Read for Friday, June 11
Marketing Venture From Bateman and Arnett Takes Off With Orbit
Guilds Express Concern About Possible Miramax Sale
Ask the White House
For Oil's Cousin, Good Luck and Bad
Parsing Europe's New Biofuel Rules
Damon Darlin
Jenna Wortham
All Things D
AppleInsider
Ars Technica
Boy Genius Report
ReadWriteWeb
Search Engine Land
Silicon Alley Insider
Tech Trader Daily
TechCrunch
The Register
VentureBeat
Wired News
Bits offers a steady stream of news and analysis on the technology industry throughout the day from New York Times writers and freelancers. We cover start-ups , tech leaders like Google and Apple , enterprise technology , government policies and the way the Internet is changing how we live and work. Read more .
Send us e-mail with your comments
For news tips and press announcements, please use the e-mail links on the blog home page to reach our writers and editors.
Advertising and E-Commerce
Biotechnology
Company News
Enterprise Computing
Green Technology
Mergers and Finance
Misfit Bits
Music and Video
News Analysis
Silicon Valley
Venture Capital and Finance
Technology and society, Internet, futurism, video games, business technology
Internet, media, technology and society, policy and law.
Consumer electronics, consumer issues, pricing
Internet, blogs, search, cellphones
Search, Internet, online marketing, Google, Yahoo
Enterprise computing, economics of technology, Microsoft, I.B.M.
Start-ups, e-commerce, venture capital, Twitter, eBay, digital culture, technology and society
Consumer electronics, video game business, Silicon Valley, Internet gambling, Internet pornography
Technology and society, consumer issues, digital culture
Internet, technology and society, policy and law, security, social networks, electronic commerce, eBay, Amazon.com
Enterprise computing, software, network technology, semiconductors, trends in corporate technology
Internet, Web start-ups, digital culture, communications, convergence, N.Y. tech scene
Select Month
April 2010
March 2010
February 2010
January 2010
December 2009
November 2009
October 2009
September 2009
August 2009
April 2009
March 2009
February 2009
January 2009
December 2008
November 2008
October 2008
September 2008
August 2008
April 2008
March 2008
February 2008
January 2008
December 2007
November 2007
October 2007
September 2007
August 2007
January 2007
Twitter Buys an Analytics Company
Back to Top
Copyright 2010
The New York Times Company
Terms of Service
Corrections
First Look
Contact Us
Work for Us
• Tag us • Disclaimer • © 2008-2010 by Sebastian courtesy of Virtual Brains Inc •